NCERT Solutions for Class 9 English Beehive Chapter 9 – If I Were You

NCERT Solutions for Class 9 English Beehive Chapter 9 If I Were You explain the one-act play by Douglas James. Gerrard, a playwright who lives alone in a cottage, is surprised by an Intruder with a gun. The Intruder, who has killed a policeman, plans to murder Gerrard and take over his identity because the two look alike. Gerrard stays calm, makes witty remarks and invents a story that he too is a criminal on the run from the police. The Intruder believes him, and Gerrard tricks him into the cupboard and locks him in.

The questions and answers given below follow the NCERT textbook and the CBSE exam pattern. They cover the humour in the play, how Gerrard's intelligence and presence of mind helped him, the qualities of Gerrard and the Intruder, and the important dialogues such as "At last a sympathetic audience", "This is your big surprise", "They can't hang me twice" and "I said it with bullets". Students can use these solutions to revise the chapter and prepare for class tests.

NCERT Solutions for Class 9 English Beehive Chapter 9 – If I Were You

NCERT Solutions for Class 9 English Beehive Chapter 9 – If I Were You

Q1. Comment on the use of humour in the play 'If I Were You'.

Answer: The play 'If I Were You' is about a criminal who tries to steal Gerrard's identity, and Gerrard, a playwright, is caught unawares by him. The play has suspense as well as humour. The humour is neither boisterous nor unnatural. It is refined and subtle.
Gerrard is calm and composed throughout the play. His presence of mind makes him say such witty and sarcastic remarks that the Intruder feels irritated and baffled.
Gerrard doesn't panic even though he is at gunpoint. When the Intruder threatens him to talk about himself, Gerrard says he is happy to have a sympathetic audience. When the Intruder proposes to live in his cottage, Gerrard, rather than being shocked, says, "You have not been invited." Gerrard's straightforwardness also adds humour to the play. Talking about the Intruder's looks, Gerrard remarks, "You are not particularly decorative."
Thus, throughout the play, there is a thread of humour that makes it interesting.

Q2. Describe how Gerrard's intelligence, presence of mind and sense of humour helped him to trick the Intruder. (Answer in about 120 words.)

Answer: Gerrard was an intelligent person. He did not show any sign of nervousness when an intruder entered with a gun. On the contrary, he tried to engage the Intruder in conversation to know more about him. With his funny remarks he kept himself calm and the atmosphere light, but this annoyed the Intruder. In no time, he started to fabricate a criminal story, posing as a wanted criminal as soon as he realised the true intentions of the Intruder. His story was so convincing that it made the Intruder believe him and they planned an escape. Gerrard's plan was actually a trap into which the Intruder fell. It is true that Gerrard's presence of mind, intelligence and sense of humour turned the tables.

Q3. Write a paragraph each about Gerrard and the Intruder to show what qualities they have.

Answer: Gerrard
Gerrard is a playwright. He is cool and humorous. He faces a life-threatening situation when a hardcore criminal enters his house intending to kill him and steal his identity to outwit the police. The Intruder is smart and flashy. He manages to gather some information regarding Gerrard. Gerrard is humorous, witty and clever. He speaks humorously in spite of the danger he faces. He cooks up a story and makes the Intruder believe that he too is a criminal trying to escape arrest. In spite of the imminent danger, he remains cool and confident. He cleverly locks the Intruder inside his cupboard.
The Intruder
The Intruder is flashy and smart but not as smart as Gerrard. He seems to be confident but at the same time he is confused. He is a murderer trying to escape from the police. He is clever and a keen observer. It is evident from the fact that he keenly observes Gerrard's daily routine. He thinks that he can kill Gerrard and impersonate him to escape from the police.

Q4. "This is your big surprise." (i) Where has this been said in the play? (ii) What is the surprise?

Answer: (i) These words have been said twice in the play. In the first instance it is said by the Intruder when he reveals his plan to kill Gerrard. In the second it is said by Gerrard himself when he is about to tell his made-up story to the Intruder.
(ii) The Intruder's surprise is his plan to kill Gerrard, take up his identity and live a hassle-free life, fooling the cops who are looking for him. On the contrary, Gerrard's surprise is the story he cooked up to escape from the Intruder.

Q5. "A mystery I propose to explain." What is the mystery the speaker proposes to explain?

Answer: The Intruder thinks that Gerrard is a mystery man. He lives alone and meets hardly anyone. He is at home one day and gone the next. Gerrard explains this mystery to the Intruder saying that he too is a murderer. He lives alone to avoid being caught by the police.
The game is up for him because things went wrong. The police arrested one of his men and he confessed everything. The cops are after him. He has made a plan to escape as he expects trouble. In fact, there is no mystery behind Gerrard. He cooked up a story to confuse the Intruder and to escape from him.

Q6. "They can't hang me twice." (i) Who says this? (ii) Why does the speaker say it?

Answer: (i) The Intruder says these words.
(ii) The Intruder has killed a policeman, for which he is going to be hanged. Even if he kills Gerrard, the maximum punishment he is going to get will be the same. It is not possible to execute a person twice.

Q7. "You'll soon stop being smart." (i) Who says this? (ii) Why does the speaker say it? (iii) What, according to the speaker, will stop Gerrard from being smart?

Answer: (i) The Intruder says this to Gerrard.
(ii) The Intruder says this because he doesn't want to disclose his identity.
(iii) The Intruder thinks that Gerrard will stop being smart when he learns of his plan to kill him and take his identity. He thinks that Gerrard will be scared to hear such a thing.

Q8. What is Gerrard's profession? Quote the parts of the play that support your answer.

Answer: Gerrard is a playwright. There are many dialogues in the play indicating the same. Look at the following dialogues:
• "This is all very melodramatic, not very original, perhaps, but..."
• "At last a sympathetic audience!"
• "In most melodramas the villain is foolish enough to delay his killing long enough to be frustrated."
• "I said, you were luckier than most melodramatic villains."
• "That's a disguise outfit; false moustaches and what not."
• "Sorry I can't let you have the props in time for rehearsal, I've had a spot of bother - quite amusing. I think I'll put it in my next play."

Q9. "I said it with bullets." (i) Who says this? (ii) What does it mean? (iii) Is it the truth? What is the speaker's reason for saying this?

Answer: (i) Gerrard says these words.
(ii) It means that Gerrard has killed somebody.
(iii) No, this is not true. Gerrard wants to trick the Intruder and wants him to believe that Gerrard too has murdered someone. He wants to do this so that the Intruder thinks that taking Gerrard's identity will be of no use to him.

Q10. Why does the Intruder choose Gerrard as the man whose identity he wants to take on?

Answer: The Intruder is Gerrard's look-alike. He is a murderer on the run. He thinks that he can kill Gerrard and impersonate him to escape from the police.

Q11. "At last a sympathetic audience." (i) Who says this? (ii) Why does he say it? (iii) Is he sarcastic or serious?

Answer: (i) Gerrard says this to the Intruder.
(ii) He says this because the Intruder wants to have a nice talk with him.
(iii) Gerrard is sarcastic in saying this.

Q12. Why does Gerrard say to the Intruder that if he shoots him, the Intruder will hang for sure?

Answer: Gerrard wants to convince the Intruder that he will not be at peace if he impersonates him after killing him. Gerrard further explains that he himself is a criminal living an unstable life and he is being hunted by the police.

Related Study Material on Extramarks